quasi random (kaolinfire) wrote,
quasi random
kaolinfire

an interesting thread on perception/reality

> Well, that's being a bit dramatic. I think that all it leads to is not
> having answered the question. I've yet to find anything that leads to a
> dissolution of reality. (that statement's just BEGGING for splorg-flames)

5-MeO-Di-Methyl Tryptamine.

fifteen minutes of lack of reality.

> Yeah, that's the first kind of response that I expected. That doesn't
> change reality.. only perception.


Reality and perception...

we only know reality through perception...

though I suppose you'd argue for a pill you could take, for instance, that
would change other people's perceptions, the "consensus" reality being more
important than any individual's?

> It isn't only consensus. It's meaningful relevance. To argue, as, for
> example, Berkeley did, that matter doesn't exist, is to make a meaningless
> statement. An easy way to counter it is the famous rebuttal, "I refute it
> THUS!" while kicking a stone.

Die, Berkeley, Die! =)

Though I'm not too fond of that rebuttal, either. The heart of the rebuttal
being more, "well, so fucking what if it doesn't exist? that and $2 will
let you make a collect call AND not get your ass beaten."

okay, right, I didn't say anything you didn't just. la la. :)

> And if you had a book by which a person who had no knowledge of chinese
> could take in writings in chinese and respond to them in an intelligent
> fashion, then you will have instantiated 'understanding' without any
> meaningful knowledge or interpretation.

I hate Searle. I hate the Chinese Room Argument. :)

What is understanding? (checking dictionary.com out of curiosity... "To
perceive and comprehend the nature and significance of, grasp")

perceive: [dictionary.com is going REALLY slowly right now; I've never had it
being anything but totally speedy before... I wonder what's up... "connection
refused when attempting to contact www.dictionary.com" ...?]

perceive -- to become aware of through any of the senses, or to achieve
understanding of. (ooh, I love circular definitions... grumble...)

right. so I guess in the first bit of perceive there's pretty blatant
presumption of consciousness. what the hell is consciousness?

"the conscious". hmm. right. getting somewhere?

hmm... pick a definition, any definition: "capable of thought, will, or
perception". I think that's as good as it gets for what we're talking about.

I think there, the "system" would have consciousness. not the book, nor the
"person"/robot acting things out, but the system. by definition. Now,
making that book is difficult. I think the trick there is to make the book
such that it makes itself. Preferably by attaching the book to the robot,
giving the book/robot full proprioception and perception, full ability to
respond to the environment... and then maybe you can start talking about its
consciousness.

Whether it has a soul or not is something to argue with the religious fanatics.

> Argument for such a device presumes that the ddevice could possibly exist,
> and I say it couldn't. If you ditched the 'pill' idea and said you simply
> had an abstract 'machine' that altered everyone's perceptions, INCLUDING
> the applicability of those perceptions to their lives in every measurable
> means, then yes, you'd be changing reality. And then you, being the only
> one who does not interact with the world in the same way as everyone else,
> would be the one in the loony bin.

Hmm. This sounds fun.



So, if and only if, I could dose EVERY HUMAN CONSCIOUSNESS with say, a week's
worth of LSD, then I would have changed reality for a week? Because there
wouldn't be a soul to say I didn't? :)
Subscribe

  • What GUD Monster are you?

    Just in time for the holiday... "Don't click on yourself!" monster: You're the Sarita virus from The Infinite Monkeys Protocol by Lavie Tidhar…

  • In distributed internet

    In distributed internet, haikus write you! Haiku 2 for kaolinfire i'm up earlier than i can really bear i had the privilege @…

  • For lack of anything of substance

    Your rainbow is shaded green. What is says about you: You are an intelligent person. You feel strong ties to nature and your mood…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment